Behringer SM200 Demo - mellow

So your band plays a song, based around keyboards and violins. Very mellow etc. You want to add some guitar to any live gigs you do. So you get your gain relatively high to get that buttery lushness out of your neck pickup... you add just a pinch of harmonizer, some delay and reverb... Mostly - it sounds good. Well - mostly. Your high gain may be giving you some lush tones but the attack and the sustain don’t really fit with the song’s overall concept. So it ends up sounding like crap. What do you need?