Trudeau’s new online censorship law - Problems with Bill C-63 / the Online Arms Law
The Trudeau government has proposed a new law to regulate the internet, and it has major constitutional problems.
Please write to your member of Parliament using this online portal we created:
The Online Harms Act would limit constitutionally-protected expression in the following ways:
- The Bill would create a new process for individuals and groups to complain to the Canadian Human Rights Commission that online speech directed at them is discriminatory. The tribunal could order fines of up to $50,000, and awards of up to $20,000 paid to complainants, who in some cases would be anonymous. Findings would be based on a mere “balance of probabilities” standard rather than the criminal standard of proof beyond a reasonable doubt.
- The subjectivity of defining “hate speech” will lead to punishments for protected speech. The mere threat of human rights complaints will chill large amounts of protected speech.
- The Bill would increase the maximum sentence for “advocating genocide” from five years in prison to life in prison. That means words alone could lead to life imprisonment.
- The Bill would allow judges to put prior restraints on people who they believe on reasonable grounds may commit speech crimes in the future. The accused would be forced to choose between imprisonment or a “recognizance to keep the peace” that may be accompanied by severe conditions such as giving a bodily sample, refraining from drugs and alcohol, giving up firearms and wearing an ankle monitor.
- The Bill would require social media companies to “minimize the risk that users of the service will be exposed to harmful content” with the threat of massive fines if they don’t properly mitigate the risk. Social media companies will likely err on the side of caution and block large amounts of speech that is close to the legal line.
- The Bill would require social media companies to provide a mechanism for users to flag content that they believe is “harmful content,” which is defined as including speech that “foments hatred.” This will inevitably lead to censorship of legally-protected speech.
- The Bill would require social media companies to report on how they dealt with perfectly legal but otherwise “harmful content” that “the operator had reasonable grounds to believe posed a risk of significant psychological or physical harm.” This appears aimed at encouraging social media companies to censor speech that the government cannot outlaw.
In this episode I mention a tweet thread by my colleague Josh Dehaas. You can read it here:
I also mention an op-ed by my colleague Joanna Baron. You can read it here:
I also talk about two important Supreme Court cases about hate speech. You can read those cases here:
Please write to your MP to express your concerns about this law!
1 view
0
0
1 month ago 00:00:00 1
Trudeau’s “Tantrums“ Put Stryker Deal on Hold, India’s WhAP Emerges Winner | From The Frontline
1 month ago 00:00:00 1
India Vs Canada LIVE | How Trudeau’s Anti-India Rant Is Linked To BRICS’ De-Dollarisation Drive
1 month ago 00:06:38 1
Trudeau’s Officials Leaked India-linked Intel to Washington Post | Vantage with Palki Sharma
1 month ago 00:24:12 1
What does New Brunswick’s election mean for Trudeau and Poilievre? | Power & Politics
1 month ago 00:11:50 1
16th BRICS SUMMIT 2024 LIVE UPDATES: What To Expect From BRICS Summit? Inside Details
1 month ago 00:10:28 1
Canada’s Worst Terror Attack: How Khalistanis Targeted Air India Flight 182 | Flashback
1 month ago 00:04:41 1
‘So far no evidence…’MEA slams Justin Trudeau for ‘lack of evidentiary proof’ in killing of Nijjar
1 month ago 00:55:35 1
Debate With Arnab: India Calls Out Trudeau’s Vote Bank Politics, Rejects Preposterous Imputations
1 month ago 09:36:20 1
Canada India News | Former Canadian Minister Mackay Reveals PM Trudeau’s ’Anti-India Agenda’ | N18G
1 month ago 00:12:34 1
Canadian Liberal MP Says ’Trudeau Has To Go’ | Five Eyes Alliance Backs Canadian Probe
1 month ago 00:07:34 1
Trudeau’s Diplomatic War with India Backfires, Criticised by Canadian Media
1 month ago 00:15:52 1
“Flying by the seat of Justin Trudeau’s pants…”Top US security expert blasts Canada Khalistan policy
1 month ago 00:42:53 1
Trudeau says India “decided not to cooperate” as New Delhi, Ottawa expels 6 diplomats each | FULL
1 month ago 00:26:40 1
Justin Trudeau Says Canada Expelled 6 Indian Diplomats Because New Delhi Refused To Co-operate |N18G
1 month ago 00:12:46 1
Canada India row: What is Trudeau’s evidence? | DW News
1 month ago 00:55:15 1
LIVE: India Downgrades Relations With Canada, Withdraws Top Diplomat | Vantage with Palki Sharma
1 month ago 00:03:07 1
Canada Is Geopolitically Very Insignificant, Says, Abhijit Chavda | The Debate
2 months ago 00:02:12 1
3 in 4 Canadians think Trudeau should step down now: poll
2 months ago 01:09:59 1
30-09-24 - India’s guns on Trudeau - NY Mayor’s India links - UK State/Judiciary vs Sikhs - Beadbi
2 months ago 00:10:16 1
Getting ‘Closer Together’ with Sophie Grégoire Trudeau | Your Morning
2 months ago 00:09:57 1
Sophie Grégoire Trudeau is determined to move forward
2 months ago 00:23:49 1
What Sophie Grégoire Trudeau did next | The Current
2 months ago 00:02:50 1
Trudeau’s Key Ally Withdraws Support | Major Setback For Trudeau | NewsX
2 months ago 00:10:29 1
John Rustad VS. David Eby: Free Market vs. Government Control